Just over 3 years ago, Jdaddy and I were in the midst of making a very important decision. We were trying to decide whether to put Buddy in kindergarten, or to send him to Early 5′s.
Buddy has an August birthday. The cutoff to register a child in Michigan, at that time, was December 1st. So he technically wouldn’t be the youngest in kindergarten, but there was a good chance he would be the smallest. Buddy has consistently followed the 5-10th percentile curve on his growth chart for height and weight.
While we were considering his age and size, we were also considering the fact that he had been in preschool at his daycare for 18 months at that time. I called the school district and asked for information regarding the differences between Early 5′s and kindergarten. What I ended up learning was that Buddy already knew everything he was supposed to learn in Early 5′s.
After a lot of research, soul searching, discussion, etc., we finally made the decision to send him to kindergarten, with the understanding that we would have him repeat kindergarten if needed.
First Day of Kindergarten 2009
A year later, we found ourselves in the same place…trying to decide whether to send him on to first grade, or have him repeat kindergarten. Academically, Buddy was right on target. His kindergarten teacher had passed him to first grade, so it would be our decision to hold him back. We met with his teacher (who really wasn’t much help), once again did a lot of soul searching, and then, in the end, decided to have him repeat kindergarten.
First Day of Kindergarten 2010
Buddy was at the top of his class in kindergarten. At his fall conference, his teacher asked us if we wanted to move him to 1st grade. We had to explain to her why we held him back (his previous teacher had retired).
I have no regrets when it comes to both of the decisions we made in regards to Buddy’s schooling. I firmly believe he was ready to be challenged in kindergarten that first year, and I firmly believe that having him repeat kindergarten gave him the extra time he needed to mature, and also helped him develop some very important leadership skills.
Buddy moved on to first grade back in the fall. He was placed in a split level class, so he also has second graders in his class. Buddy is excelling! He’s performing at the top of his class, and is even reading a full year beyond where he should be (end of second grade level). We are obviously very proud of him, and are so happy that he has such a love for learning.
1st Grade School Picture
On the other hand, because of Buster’s birthday, there was never a question as to when he would start school. His birthday is December 12th, so just after the cut off. By the time Buster starts school, he will almost be 6 years old. He’s currently in a Pre-Kindergarten class at his daycare, and will be moving to a Young 5′s class in the fall. It’s not a “true” Young/Early 5′s class, but it is formatted much like one.
Two years ago, when we were trying to decide whether to have Buddy repeat kindergarten or to move him on to first grade, I remember thinking that even if Buster had an August birthday, there would be no question…we would move him on. At the time, all I was thinking about was the fact that Buster was really smart, and ahead of his peers. By the time he was two, Buster was able to recite the entire ABC’s and count to 10…and this was just after he finally started speaking (he was a late talker).
Kindergarten round-up for our school district was held last week. I didn’t pay much attention to it at first, because Buster isn’t going to kindergarten in the fall. Late last week, I started thinking about the past and how we had been disappointed that he couldn’t start school this year. In the past year, I’ve completely changed my mind. I’m so glad we have another year before he goes to school. I don’t know if it’s because he’s my “baby” and sending him to school means moving on to another chapter in our lives (and makes me want to bawl my eyes out), or if it’s because he seems/acts so much younger than Buddy did at this age. I can’t honestly say whether or not he really does act younger than Buddy at this age, but I was always in such a hurry to have Buddy grow up, that I didn’t really take time to enjoy every moment. I was always looking towards the next milestone, rather than enjoying the one that was just achieved. I know I’m not the only one. This is a huge issue with our society. We are constantly pushing our kids to do more, be better, act older, grow up faster. I could go on and on about this, but that’s not the point.
The point is, I’m so relieved that I get one more year to just let Buster be little.
May 2012
This post linked with Things I Can’t Say for Pour Your Heart Out and parenting BY dummies for Wordful Wednesday.